While there were many deserving contenders for the most stylish mom-to-be in 2009, there is only one winner. Beating out models Gisele Bündchen, Heidi Klum, and Camila Alves, as well as maternity clothing designer Nicole Richie, Sarah Michelle Gellar was voted favorite fashionable expectant mama. Her hubby Freddie Prinze Jr. was crowned favorite new dad of 2009, so it seems fitting that his lovely wife would be awarded as well.

The star of Buffy certainly had a glow about her during her pregnant months, and she outfitted her bump beautifully with flowy frocks and flattering workout attire. Keeping her look fresh and natural, she made pregnancy seem all too easy and enjoyable.