Last week, I asked you if you thought the pregnant man was a hoax and you were split on the issue.
But, the mystery is solved since Thomas Beatie is set to appear on today's Oprah. So if you have to see it to believe it, tune in and watch as they perform an ultrasound and show off the nursery.



House of Fraser
Too bad I won't be able to watch it. This is kinda weird. Hmmm
1I was really surprised when I saw this story yesterday, and I was actually going to make an effort to watch Oprah until I figured out the mystery of the pregnant "man". I feel a lot of people are going to be disappointed when they see the real story.
2Ok, so I see the little transgender tag there and I am assuming that it is really a woman. Wow, a pregnant woman dressed like a man. Surprised Oprah would care about this.
3I know, the whole thing is so sensationalized. It is a person who used to be a woman who is transitioning to being a man. It's not as if a person born with male anatomy is all of a sudden pregnant. I guess the reason why Oprah is interested is because SOCIETY-wise, this is a person walking around who sees themselves and other people see him as male, and is pregnant.
4Also, I am wondering if it is "safe", so to say, for a woman who has (or still is?) receiving testosterone hormones to have a baby. Hm.
5j2e, that is a good question. I assume he is being followed carefully by a medical team.
6j2e1n9, It's an interesting point and it's one of the things I'm most curious to learn about in the interview today. On GMA last week, Lisa Masterson, an OBGYN at Cedars Sinai, said that he should most definitely stop the testosterone injections because it could actually affect the reproductive parts of the growing fetus. She said the vaginal walls of the baby could become swollen and fold over. Crazy. I HOPE he/she is minding what is best for the baby.
I wonder if he will end up looking like the formal "she" at time of delivery.
7I believe he/she stopped taking testosterone before the pregnancy. I'm pretty much over the whole thing.
8I think it's disgusting. Sorry. I don't need my kids thinking all of this is appropriate. Women have kids. If you choose to become a man you choose to give up that. I truly believe it's just wrong.
9I agree, erthed. If she/he really decided to become a man, then that is the choice. It seems hypocritical to then become pregnant. That is a completely female experience, and she decided womanhood was not for her.
10okay, NOT A MAN, hello its not a MAN! yes on paper "he" is and "he" has had hormones, but we cant sincerely say "man pregnant!" and take it LITERALLY like some dude (with a bad 90's goatee) got knocked up!
Plus, if "he" really thinks of himself as a man...than why is he pregnant, which is specifically a womans issue?
seriously I need money too, but you dont see me eating cat treats, glueing fur on me, wearing ears and announcing that me, a cat, can drive a car.
that poor child
11I hate that this is being sensationalized. I have a feeling that this won't be the last pregnant transgender individual we see walking around. I have no problem with people making this choice, but the whole hormone thing scares me for the baby's sake. I mean I didn't take a Tylenol or Cold meds for 10 months but Hormone injections are okay? Just don't get how it can be healthy for the baby.
12makes me feel sick. in addition to everything said above it occurs to me that the reason for the pregnancy is freak-show status. do it in private, for the joy of being a parent, for the love of your unborn children with your partner, not so you can go on oprah and dish the juicy details. blech.
13I don't have a problem with it. My big issue is that the government recognizes him as a man when he's obviously not, and allowed the two of them to marry and receive all the benefits of married couples. Technically, Thomas is still a woman. That makes them a lesbian couple, which is illegal. It isn't fair to make exceptions. All or nothing, but getting rid of your boobs and taking testosterone shouldn't make you any more special than any other gay couple.
14I agree Lickety - This is obviously more for the financial gain of things. Why else are you on Oprah and telling your sotory to anyone who will listen.
15colormesticky- that's a really good point.
and yes, I fail to understand the drama with this story. I was like whoa, man pregnant??? but as soon as I read the article I thought yeah, that's not a man. that's a woman who didn't finish surgery.
16So someone with an intact female reproductive system is having a baby? YOU DON'T SAY.
Colormesticky-That's exactly what bothers me....more than the "holy crap a man becomes pregnant!" thing.
17All that really matters here is that they are a happy family.
Anyone who pooh-poohs
love in any form can suck it.
18I saw these headlines for a while and could have cared less. How stupid does one have to be to believe for even one second that a man, without ovaries and a uterus, can possibly be pregnant?
19I thought Oprah was above such sensational topics, this sounds more like a Maury episode to me.
romaniagrl, you need to read the whole story.
20For some reason, I'm not interested in this person's story. My point was that I was annoyed with the media for making headlines such as "pregnant male"! I think anyone who has half a brain can figure out that no "normally" endowed male can possibly become pregnant. Why do things always have to get twisted and sensationalized?
21he stopped taking testosterone before trying to conceive, if i recall correctly from the article on advocate.com.
people here sure are quick to judge! i think it's great to challenge gender roles, even if it is difficult for many people to wrap their minds around this.
i also don't think he and his partner are doing this for the money. i think it's a good way to bring trans / & gender issues up for the general public that they typically don't think about.
i think it's pretty awesome, myself.
22"Sorry. I don't need my kids thinking all of this is appropriate." Erthed, it's unfortunate you don't let your kids have a mind of their own. Hopefully one day they will realize being an individual means forming your own ideas of what is right or wrong.
23I'm watching the show now - these people don't seem to be telling their story for financial reasons. I find their situation very moving and interesting. Particularly the part when Thomas said something to the effect of "I don't feel feminine for being pregnant. Reproduction is a human desire, and I have the right to have biological children."
24I feel very disappointed in the doctors who declined to treat this couple - a person is a person, doesn't matter what they look like on the outside, everyone is entitled to medical care. Those docs wouldn't turn down a patient for any other issue regarding looks (such as if a patient were "ugly" or "hairy" or "too skinny" etc.), the fact that Thomas looks like a man on the outside shouldn't matter to a medical professional.
It makes me ill to even look at this freak, passing on freak genes to a new generation. How very sad.
25And why doesn't he get some antennas transplanted into his head, he can then claim he is a martian also!
26DarkRayne I hope you never breed.
27I saw it and it was actually quite sad. They seemed really lovely and not in it for the money, although you can never really tell. Nancy's 2 elder daughters were really supportive.
I don't like the way it was all sensationalised though to make it seem like it was a man who was pregnant when he was physically still female just without the breasts. I agree with colormesticky regarding the inconsistency with the laws for gay couples and this couple who is essentially a lesbian couple.
28It's not freak of nature that a naturally "born woman" carry a child.He/She must have been very confused during gender re-assignment..."Oh I want a penis, but save my uterus".Talk about gender confusion.This one takes the cake!Come on Oprah give us a break!
29Notice to the world, "Men do not get pregnant!" Having a surgery does not make a person a man. If you were born a woman, you are still a woman. How ignorant can we become as a society?
30Akirstin that's a pretty harsh comment. So when someone doesn't agree with you it's OK to be mean?
31This sick and twisted. Oprah what have u resulted to. U should have just hooked up with Jerry Spinger. In this case you are no different from the foolishness he has on his shows. This sick and unnatural. Men cannot have babies. He is a woman. Dont care how much drugs, injections,facial hair or mens clothing you put on this character. She is still a woman.
32I am absolutely disgusted by this subject matter. And to celebrate it is even more revolting. Come on Oprah. What the hell.
33yeah, *I'm* the harsh one here.
34Actually, you are Akirstin... maybe not the only one, but you are.
35Oprah wants the world to have sympathy for this sort of behavior?? For what?? These people have problems with the way life really is. They have life so confused, and so does she. You are supposed to love everyone, but this just takes the cake. You don't have to go along with the choices people make, and make it okay just because a celebrity endorses such behavior. This is just wrong. This is just asking for a freak show. I guess this woman and her woman got what they wanted to help pay for the medical bills. Now it really would be a medical event if a man really got pregnant. This has been happening to women since forever. Its nothing new, so get over it.
36I don't see what the hugs fuss is. There is nothing wrong with this!
37Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.